Skip to content

ecobee vs Nest vs Amazon: which budget smart thermostat?

By the Plugged-In Home editors · Updated

Researched, not lab-tested · We may earn a commission from links on this page. How we choose

Top pickBest budget thermostat for Apple Homeecobee Smart Thermostat Essential
Apple Home Yes
Check price on Amazon for ecobee Smart Thermostat Essential (opens in a new tab)

Top pick = the best fit for most people. Highest score = the best at its specific job. How we score

Quick answer

Pick by the assistant you use. Alexa-only homes save the most with the Amazon Smart Thermostat. Apple Home users, or anyone with hot and cold rooms, should get the ecobee Essential and add a room sensor. Google homes should get the Nest Thermostat, which also works in Apple and Alexa homes through Matter.

Key takeaways
  • Amazon: cheapest, Alexa only, needs a C-wire.
  • ecobee Essential: every assistant, add-on room sensors.
  • Nest Thermostat: Matter, clean design, doesn’t learn your schedule.
  • The Nest Learning Thermostat is the premium step up.

Best budget thermostat for Apple Home: ecobee Smart Thermostat Essential

The Essential works with Apple Home, Alexa, Google Assistant and SmartThings, and it supports ecobee’s SmartSensors for rooms that run hot or cold. It skips the occupancy radar and speaker of ecobee’s pricier models.

What we like
  • Works with Apple Home, Alexa, Google and SmartThings
  • Supports add-on room sensors
  • Reliable and easy to use
Watch out for
  • No occupancy radar or built-in assistant
  • Basic screen and build

Skip it if you have no C-wire and don’t want to fit the adapter.

Nest looks for less: Google Nest Thermostat

The Nest Thermostat has supported Matter since April 2023, so it isn’t only for Google homes. It won’t learn your routine by itself and has no remote sensors, so set a schedule once in the app.

Nest looks for less
Google Nest Thermostat
8.1/10Apple Home Yes (Matter)
What we like
  • Matter support, so it works in Apple Home too
  • Clean design, easy install
  • Frequent sales
Watch out for
  • Doesn’t learn your schedule on its own
  • No remote room sensors

Skip it if your home has hot and cold rooms that need remote sensors.

Cheapest thermostat for Alexa: Amazon Smart Thermostat

Built with Honeywell, this is the cheapest name-brand option. It only works with Alexa, needs a C-wire (an adapter is sold separately) and has no room sensors.

Cheapest thermostat for Alexa
Amazon Smart Thermostat
7.6/10Apple Home No
What we like
  • The cheapest name-brand smart thermostat
  • Alexa Hunches can adjust it automatically
  • Wall plate included
Watch out for
  • Alexa only: no Google or Apple
  • Needs a C-wire (adapter sold separately)

Skip it if you use Google or Apple Home, or need room sensors.

Check your wiring first

Most smart thermostats need a C-wire for constant power. Take a photo of your current thermostat’s wires before buying. If you want the full premium experience, read our Nest Learning Thermostat review. For savings, see do smart thermostats save money? Have a heat pump? See smart thermostats for heat pumps.

Side by side

Product
Top pick
ecobee Essential
Nest Thermostat
Amazon
Nest Learning
Our score8.4/108.1/107.6/108.9/10Highest score
Best forBest budget thermostat for Apple HomeNest looks for lessCheapest thermostat for AlexaBest smart thermostat
Apple HomeYesYes (Matter)NoYes (Matter)
Google / AlexaBothBothAlexa onlyBoth
Room sensorsAdd-onNoNo1 included
Typical priceUsually under $150Usually under $150Usually under $100Usually under $300
Where to buyCheck price for ecobee Smart Thermostat Essential (opens in a new tab)Check price for Google Nest Thermostat (opens in a new tab)Check price for Amazon Smart Thermostat (opens in a new tab)Check price for Google Nest Learning Thermostat (4th Gen) (opens in a new tab)

Top pick = the best fit for most people. Highest score = the best at its specific job. How we score

Frequently asked questions

What is a C-wire?

The ‘common’ wire that gives a thermostat constant power. If you don’t have one, ecobee includes or sells a Power Extender Kit, Nest has a Power Connector, and Amazon sells an adapter.

Bottom line
Top pickecobee Smart Thermostat Essential

ecobee’s cheapest thermostat, with Apple Home support and room-sensor add-ons.

If that’s not you: Nest Thermostat, nest looks for less · Amazon Smart Thermostat, cheapest thermostat for Alexa

Filed under: Thermostats · ecobee · Nest · Alexa · Comparison

Related